Saturday, November 21, 2026

A Model Of Complexity

On Friday, Finominal wrote about Global X Moderate Aggressive ETF Portfolio. Here are a couple of screen shots to list them all out.



Kudos to them first of all for using funds from other fund providers in their models, not all providers do that. They even have very narrow based funds from other providers too like SKYY and PBE. If you count though, that's 26 ETFs, that is a lot for a model portfolio, really a lot. 

Finominal notes that the portfolio has a 25% weighting to fixed income but that the fixed income sleeve doesn't contribute any risk because it is mostly short duration. It looks like there are seven fixed income funds assuming PFFD is in the equity sleeve. Seven could probably be winnowed down to two funds, maybe even one. BUG, HERO and QTUM are all narrow, themed funds that each have less than a 1% weighting. 

The portfolio critique picked on owning both DYNF and QUS. I noticed that too but they do differ from each other.

And weighted proportionally, the DYNF/QUS combo did better than SPY for the last five years.


They suggest simplifying the portfolio with 80% ACWI/20% AGG. The portfolio as presented seems more complex than necessary for the value added (it lags the 80/20 benchmark but has a higher Sharpe Ratio) but two funds is probably too simple.

Amplify threw its hat into the autocallable ring with YO that in addition to a high targeted yield of SOFR plus 8%, it also offers a 25% downside buffer. The expectation should not be no sensitivity to equity market volatility, it was down 2.23% on Friday, but if the buffer works, it will protect based on the maturity of the notes held in the fund which is five years. This past week is an indication that five years is a long time to wait for the buffer to protect your investment. There is also a mechanism where any missed coupon payments due to a very large decline could be made up when the underlying recovers. Note the key word is could, could be made up. 

Most of these really are hot sauce, if you want to dabble, I would go small. I'm going to continue to study these but the only ones I would consider for clients would be the two from Janus. High, single digit yields is still a fantastic yield with nowhere near the volatility of the rest of the space. ACSP from ProShares targets 18-19% and as Dennis Eckersley might say, it moves 5% in either direction just to stay in shape.  

Here's a chart with a few funds we've looked at recently and also a few from a while ago versus VBAIX. The context is whether they could be replacements for VBAIX.


PRPFX is the outlier to the downside in the current event due to its large weighting to gold. Here's how they did for 2022 except for ENDW which wasn't around yet.

The chart is price only so that huge drop off for AQRIX was its annual distribution. I think the point of these last two charts is to reiterate that valid strategies cannot always be the best strategies. 

As a quick follow up on DYMIX that we mentioned yesterday. It will be paying out a 19% distribution which the fund literature says will be taxed as ordinary income. That doesn't matter in an IRA, just reinvest and be done with it. For taxable accounts though, that's a big hit. DYMIX is useful for studying what macro funds can do but I don't see ever using it. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Friday, November 20, 2026

Consequences For Excesses?

Starting out with a quick follow up from yesterday as markets went down a lot again on Friday. Oddly though, the things I follow, more of them were up today in the bigger decline versus yesterday's slightly smaller decline. 


For a long time here and in client letters we've been talking about obvious excesses in the tech sector while being clear to say there was no way to know when or if there would ever be a consequence for those obvious excesses. If there was no way to know when or if there would be consequences then the only protection was to be underweight versus the index. Zero weight was not/is not practical but being underweight was/is practical. 

For the last six months, the iShares Semiconductor ETF (SOXX) is down 40% as you can see. Since the beginning of October, SOXX is down 35%. I have no idea what will happen but that seems awfully fast. I'm not trying to predict anything, more like just read the room. Fast declines tend to snap back quickly so maybe this one will too?

Where we've spent a lot of time trying to understand autocallable ETFs, this event has been a great chance to learn more about how they behave when markets get hit. Some of the declines have been massive. Those are just Friday's declines.


I was talking to a buddy today who said he's concerned about all the stuff going on with outages and the like. I'm not really concerned that there will be some sort of societal level breakdown but similar to Covid, there could certainly be some inconveniences. If you haven't already done so, it's a good idea to add second factor authentication to all your accounts. There's no reason not to have extra batteries on hand, a little cash in the house, get a little ahead on food (I'm not saying doomsday levels) and for us a little bit of gasoline which is for our ATV and generator. I'd say it's always a good idea to have some level of preparedness for emergencies if you want to think of it that way or a little less dramatically, preparedness for inconveniences.

The rest of the post from here was written a couple of days ago but events got in the way. 

The new iShares Macro AlphaBeta Active ETF (GMIX) takes a page out of ReturnStacked's playbook allocating 100% to large cap domestic equities and 100% to global macro so it is leveraged. Here's a write up from Blackrock in support of the new fund. 

iShares has a newer ETF that is in the macro realm with IALT and so far, that fund has done pretty well. I saw some chatter though that the macro sleeve of GMIX might look more like PBAIX which is a Blackrock fund I'd never heard of before. PBAIX is a 5 star fund and it has done well but I wouldn't say it's done better than some of the other macro funds we've looked at. As I learn more about it, maybe it will turn out that it takes a different path to a similar result as the others which would make it interesting. 


RDMIX is a ReturnStacked product that similar to GMIX has 100% equity/100% macro. The latest incarnation goes back to the start of 2025. The ReturnStacked guys don't suggest 100% or 50% of a portfolio into their funds but the backtest maybe gives a little color on how equities and macro could work together. 

Staying in the macro realm, the other day we mentioned the Victory Pioneer Multi-Asset Income Fund (PMFYX). Despite the name, it is not a straight forward fixed income fund. It is legit multi asset. Morningstar categorized it as Global Moderate Allocation. This is from the fund's July 30 factsheet.

It goes pretty far afield. A good portion of its high sixes yield, comes from equity linked notes in a similar manner as how JEPI uses equity linked notes. That is not a precise explanation but thinking of them as short term autocallables might give some context. 


This chart is helpful for framing what I think are different objectives. PMFYX isn't really a stand alone fixed income fund and it doesn't trade that way. Similar to AQRIX it seems like a potential replacement for VBAIX so maybe calling it macro isn't fair. PBAIX does look like a replacement for a stand alone fixed income fund, at least what I think people want bond funds to look like with very low volatility and very shallow drawdowns. It hasn't had a down year in our ten year backtest.

If you think you want to dabble in macro funds, I would suggest trying to draw a conclusion about what you think it is trying to do. Right or wrong, I don't think PBAIX is a replacement for VBAIX. Right or wrong, PMFYX very well could be...more so than PBAIX anyway.


You can decide for yourself whether the above is compelling or not. There's not much differentiation over time except 2022. Portfolio 1 was down 6.01% that year, Portfolio 2 was down 8.45% compared to a drop of 16.87% for VBAIX. In other words it differentiated when investors most needed it to. In 2023, 2024 and 2025 both were very similar to VBAIX but this year as bonds have struggled price-wise again, Portfolios 1 and 2 are way ahead again. 

This next chart throws a different type of macro fund into the mix with DYMIX.


It's a shorter lookback because DYMIX is a newer fund. DYMIX looks much different in terms of growth rate, volatility and drawdowns. Higher growth rates aren't the only determining factor. Anyone who cares about this sort of alternative needs to consider not just the growth rate but how it would fit in with their other holdings. There's no way to know how well they will do in the future for their respective growth rates but it is reasonable to conclude that PBAIX will be far less volatile than DYMIX.


In terms of correlations, I'd be more confident in PBAIX maintaining it's low correlation to VBAIX but based on DYMIX' volatility, I would expect the correlation to VBAIX to be more volatile too. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Thursday, November 19, 2026

This Is Why

I think we can call what is going on in markets as being a fast decline. While this is not fun, market history tells us that slower declines have tended to be more problematic. Look at how slowly the market rolled over from the internet bubble and at the start of the Financial Crisis. Now think about the end of 2018, the Covid Crash and the Tariff Panic. They fell hard and fast and snapped back quickly. Down 6% in a month seems closer to being a fast decline. From my time at Fisher Investments and an indicator I have cited before, to the extent bear markets start slowly, look for an average 2% decline for three months in a row. Anything could happen from here of course but for now, this seems fast.


The above chart is a great example of why you diversify your diversifiers. Clients own all of those except for TAIL, and actually for gold I use GLDM.

BTAL and CAOS are generally working. CAOS responds a little better to declines that are even faster than the current one but up a little is ok. Managed futures tends to do better with longer, slower  declines than where we are at this point. It could be doing well now as a matter of luck like during the Covid Crash so I am optimistic that it would start to become additive if this in fact does become a more serious event. Gold has had long runs where it had struggled and lately has been a short run where it has been struggling. 

I've pounded the table on diversifying your diversifiers probably to the point of being boring but right now is exactly why. Occasionally they'll all work but expecting that is not realistic. The chart is exactly why I've said I think 25% in gold is a terrible idea. I'm obviously a big believer in managed futures and while we do some interesting theoretical stuff with managed futures here, I keep the allocation in real life pretty small, mid-single digits for the most part. 

Some days my mix of diversifiers works very well and we're down a lot less and some days they are less effective, there's no way to know what will work best in the next market event or to what magnitude they will work but I think they help more often than not. To the extent they are working, times like now are why you hold on while markets are doing well. There is no way to know when the market will turn or how serious it will be.

In notes to clients I usually say something the effect that there is no way to know whether this will turn into something serious or be one we soon forget about. If it does become serious, we already know how it will end. It will just stop going down and then start to go back up, eventually making a new high. The only variable is that we don't know how long it will take. 

I've included versions of that here on the blog too. It would be great to completely nail every downturn  but "don't let the pursuit of perfection be the enemy of pretty good" or words to that effect. If you care about going down less when the markets are going down and you are going down less, that's pretty good. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The More You Put In, The More You Get Out

The WSJ had an article about a retired 63 year old sheriff's officer who retired ten years ago and transformed her love of yoga into a post retirement gig as a yoga instructor. That's a gift link. 

The article doesn't get into whether it is lucrative for her financially but I come away with the sense that it is very purposeful for her. The biggest takeaway for me from the article is how much time she put into training to be a better and more knowledgeable instructor. 

Over the years we've talked occasionally about figuring out a post retirement endeavor, whether for financial reasons or personal fulfillment. When I was a kid, I was definitely a do the absolute bare minimum to get by type of person. I started to outgrow that in college with outside activities and then started to really understand the value in my late 20's and early 30's when I was working at Schwab. Working there had its share of challenges to be sure but I got to do some cool stuff.

My entire career as an advisor was built off the back of my blogging which certainly counts as putting more in to get more out so I hope you'll take me seriously on this point if you might need to figure something out for a post retirement endeavor. Volunteering somewhere is great but you will get far more out of it being very active in the org where you volunteer. 

This comment on the article caught my eye;

Good for her. I found a post-retirement job (or is it a career transition) that is also completely unrelated to what I had been doing. I'm a bit surprised more people don't do this. Before we retire, our work choices are usually limited to things that pay a certain amount. After retirement, that restriction is lifted.

His point about being completely unrelated really resonated. I dove into this in more detail in early 2022. I think it is crucial to have very disparate interests. It makes life far more interesting and in the case of the lady featured in the WSJ article, a willingness to take on new interests and really dig in to learn makes for a more successful outcome whether success means financially or purposefully. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Monday, November 16, 2026

Clearly It Is Not Hopeless

Yahoo Finance had a couple of light reads about retirement planning; one said that "wealthy" people think they need $2.6 million to retire and the other gave a status of where people ages 55-64 stand in terms of median accumulated retirement balances. 

The "wealthy" people are only halfway to their goal and for, I don't know, non-wealthy, the median balance is $239,000. Both articles had the usual suggestions about 401k contributions and how catch up contributions work. Delaying retirement is a question that people who are behind where they need to be should ask themselves. Similarly, tough questions about downsizing or working a post retirement gig need to be sorted out too. 

Anyone who has been interested in this topic for any length of time wouldn't learn anything new from those articles and some of the comments reflected frustration over that point but there was once a day that we did not know about catch up contributions, then we read something and we did. Someone read today's articles and learned about catch up contributions for their first time so they learned something new. 

Assuming a 4% withdrawal rate, $239,000 would pay $9600 per year. That may not sound lucrative but it's not nothing either. Where we've talked about there being a line between a robust emergency fund and a retirement account, I think $239,000 fits the bill for being a retirement account. 

That's not a huge amount but at 55, there's time for it to grow considerably. If the $239,000 is split 60/40 in a 401k, the equity sleeve is currently $143,000. According to Gemini, rolling ten year average returns for the S&P 500 have been "between 10 and 11%" so let's call it 10.5%. If that projects forward at the same rate, then the $143,000 would grow to $407,000. If the remaining $96,000 of today's balance was just in cash, earning 4% then in ten years that sleeve would be worth a coincidental $143,000 for a total of  $550,000.

If they've been able to save money up to this point, we're assuming they are 55 years old, then hopefully they can continue to save. If they can put away $1000/mo and get 7.25% which is the trailing compounded total return for VBAIX over the last ten years, then future contributions would be worth $175,000 ten years from now so their total balance could be $725,000. Assuming $1000 is not heroic, a lot of these articles talking about contributing the max amount to 401ks which would be great but probably not plausible for the majority. 

A 4% withdrawal rate from $725,000 is $29,000. Pulling $29,000 and their Social Security, ok they are not killing it but this can be a very workable outcome, especially if they are mortgage free when they retire. Maybe in this scenario if these people paid off their mortgage at 60, they'd be able to put more than $1000/mo away for a few years. 

The assumed rates of return are obviously backward looking and there's no way to know if they will project forward or not. The bigger point I hope is that even if you think you're behind where you should be at whatever age, it can still work out well. 

This may not be relevant for you, reading this blog but I bet you know people for whom this would be relevant. I don't know whether someone would read those Yahoo articles and conclude it's hopeless but, clearly it is not hopeless. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Why Would Anyone Prefer This?

The other day we included a quick mention of preferred stocks and used iShares Preferred Stock ETF (PFF) as a proxy for the space. This morning, Barron's took a look at some of the yields available from some individual preferred stocks.

Of the ones they mentioned, Capital One Preferred J closed at $15.40 for a yield of 7.75% and Wells Fargo Preferred Z which was at $16.50 last week has current a yield of 7.75%. Both preferreds were issued at a $25 par value. The coupon on the Capital One J is 4.8% and for WFC Z it is 4.75%. Those price declines are pretty big and for anyone who thought they were buying a bond like instrument, it is devastating. They are both perpetual preferred stocks meaning there is no maturity date so they won't revert back to their respective par values unless interest rates go way down.


YTD, they are both down mid-teens percent.

I'm not a huge fan of taking on this kind of volatility for the fixed income sleeve of a real portfolio, we've played around with some volatile funds for blog purposes however. 


JBBB yields 6.84% and is nowhere near as volatile or sensitive to interest rates as the preferred stocks we're looking at today. PCN is a closed end fund that we've looked at a couple of times this week and is a little more volatile but pays out 450 basis points more than either preferred stock. There are easier ways to get yield than the preferred stocks. Not to mention that if interest rates keep going up, there will be yet more pain for these. 

The charts are all price only which is unfair in a way but price only gives a better feel for what owning these will actually be like. Of course investors do own these, PCN has a market cap of $800 million, but I would say that if you're willing to take on this sort of volatility in your fixed income bucket, to keep the allocation small. We looked at a 5% weighting to PCN the other day and that small of an exposure did lift the yield of the overall portfolio. You'll find different schools of thought about position sizing but small weightings can be very effective. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

IQQI Not Icky?

Barron's shared a brief research note from BMO about the "underwhelming" results of the standard 60/40 portfolio this year noting it has "clearly been held back by the bond component." BMO then tried to look ahead to what a 5% ten year yield might do to improve the results. Getting 5% would certainly be an improvement but it wouldn't help with the volatility or how reliable the ten year is as a diversifier. 


The above chart continues the same conversation we've been having for many years about avoiding duration but we added a small slice to PCN after looking at it yesterday. PCN is a hot potato of a closed end fund that has a pretty high yield. Portfolio 3, the one without PCN, yields closer to 3.1%. The backtest is short because of client holding JAAA but the outperformance is not all from 2022. The approximate 2% better CAGR over the SPY/AGG combo for the three portfolios adds up quickly in just six years. I think the drawdown and volatility numbers are meaningful but not earth shattering. 

Regarding PCN, is the extra yield worth the extra volatility? That's hard to say but the very small weighting does have a visible impact even if, again, not earth shattering. 

With the meltdown on Nvidia (NVDA), I thought it would be a good time to follow up on a couple derivative income ETFs that reference NVDA common stock.


ANV is a single stock autocallable fund from GraniteShares and NVDY is the YieldMax covered call fund. The common has not fallen enough to suspend the distributions from ANV. The barriers currently start at $139.70 and work lower from there. ANV was immune to the volatility of the common until it wasn't. 

Obviously there's no way to know where/when NVDA will bottom but the 10% drop for ANV is not bad when you think in terms of autocallables generating yield from equity volatility, the yield doesn't come from fixed income market drivers. Going forward though, ANV is likely to be more volatile than it has been because of the jump up in volatility of the common until the volatility goes back down. Trying to quantify what that will mean would be a lot of guess work. 

The price only decline in NVDY generally makes sense, it has paid out about 4% in distributions since the beginning of October. Sometimes the payout can cushion the decline but not always. I think price only is constructive because it captures the experience of being a share holder. NVDY closed Friday under $9 so my hunch is a reverse split could be coming soon.

Last one for today, Quantify Funds is throwing it hat in the broad based index, derivative income fund ring with the Income Q NASDAQ 100 Premium Income Fund (IQQI) which should start trading this week. It will not sell covered calls, it will buy deep in the money calls to capture the upside and sell put spreads to generate income. Part of the marketing is "full exposure with uncapped upside."

Covered calls cap the upside. If you buy a stock at $90 and sell calls at $100, your upside is capped at $100. XYLD and QYLD show this very plainly. They sell monthly calls and the price only returns are nowhere close to the indexes they reference. 

I was quite certain that the long call/short put spread strategy existed already somewhere in the Tuttle realm and they do with the Income Blast suite of funds. DRMP is the Tuttle Memory Stack Income Blast ETF and the green line is Roundhill Memory ETF (DRAM) which is a fair comparison. 


Selling put spreads doesn't cap upside but doing so inside of a fund would have to cap the upside in a way. The DRMP website shows the current distribution rate at 31.07%. If it pays out that much, then with each distribution, the NAV gets reduced (that's how going ex-div works). Covered call or not, a fund yielding 30% needs to overcome those ex-div reductions otherwise the NAV will erode. DRMP started out staying close on a price only basis but staying close isn't sustainable at 30%. 

Trying to piece IQQI together it looks like it will be closer to NEOS QQQI in terms of yield level and ROC distributions. 


A scenario where long call/short put spreads could be better than covered call funds would be in quick rallies. In a large decline though, long call/short put spreads could do worse than covered calls because the long calls would get hit hard and the price of the underlying could go below the long leg of the spread and stay there. If you don't know what that means, I would avoid these until you can spend time learning.

If someone is wants a covered call fund but not an NAV incinerator and long call/short put spread will look similar most of the time but with a chance for more upcapture in a fast rally? Yeah, it might be a better mouse trap occasionally. I'd be more interested in one of these that referenced the S&P 500. For now, it does not appear anyone has filed for an S&P 500 version but if IQQI works close to how it's been billed there will be. If/when an S&P 500 version comes, in addition to comparing to covered call funds, I would also want to compare to WTPI from WisdomTree which just sells puts. 


The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Be Careful With Closed Ends

Two quick items today.

First up is a closed end fund that I don't think we've looked at before; PIMCO Corporate & Income Strategy Fund (PCN). It was mentioned in an article on Yahoo Finance that was so bad I'm not even going to link to it. PCN has done well relative to closed end funds and to AGG. Its total return has compounded at 9.15% over the last 23 years compared to 2.92% for iShares Aggregate (AGG). The yield over that time has been about 10.5% but the yield has had some variability, CEFconnect shows the yield currently at just over 12% and the leverage shows 22%. 

On a price only basis it has compounded negatively at 1.44% for a cumulative negative 28%. The negative compounding isn't necessarily a deal breaker when sized correctly. At 10 or 11% it is providing a disproportionate amount of yield for anyone who wants distributions out of their portfolio.


The tradeoff is a lot of volatility which is to be expected with closed end funds. They have some brutal drawdowns.


The drawdown chart hovers over the financial crisis low when it was down 66%. I highlighted a bunch of other big declines that happened along the way. The back test I built looks pretty good and if we played around with other backtests they'd probably look good too but man. Putting 30% into PCN is a hyperbolic example that I think would invite frequent misery. While a small slice is probably more palatable, I think you really have to look long and hard in the mirror for these. Barron's writes frequently about closed end funds but they don't hit on the occasional massive declines that go with the space. 

The Wall Street Journal had a doozy of an article; How To Prepare For A 60 Year Career & Save For Retirement. The tone of the comments, always read the comments, could be summed up with 60 years? GFY.

The idea of planning to work until 80 is ridiculous but is there a bigger message that might be more useful? I think there are two points. If they had replaced the word career with income steams, it would have been more useful because I think many readers took the 60 year idea literally. If someone is 80, enjoys painting and sells paintings, that seems like a great outcome compared to commuting to an office job everyday all through your 70's because you have to. A former fire board member here in Walker is a sculptor, sells pieces and until recently worked one day a week at the artists co-op in town. He's 78.

The other point for me was about optionality in case you have to work not until 80 but longer than you were planning to work. If someone is 65 and financially needs to keep at it for a little while to make their math work, it would nice to be able to do that. 

Repeating from a couple of hundred other posts;

  • Eat less sugar
  • Eat less processed food

I think it is vital to lift weights. Plenty of people do not enjoy lifting but it is vital. It can be very quick and simple to make improvements even if not a thorough full body workout. 

  • Deadlift
  • Squat
  • Farmers Carry
  • Pushups 

The picture is of a landmine squat which has very little chance of injury compared to resting the barbell on the back of your neck.


There are substitutes for deadlifts like bent over rows or dumbbells that again, greatly reduce the odds of injury. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Massive Fund Distributions

Just a couple of quick hits today starting with the Glenmede Global Secured Options Fund (NOVIX). 


That's a price only chart. Here's total return.


The fund isn't very yieldy. The one huge drop huge drop off is a $9 capital gains distribution. In an IRA account it doesn't matter, the distribution can just be reinvested but in a taxable account, that could be a serious problem. Not every strategy fits neatly into the ETF wrapper but where you have a choice, go with the ETF. Mutual funds report any unrealized gains or losses to help people avoid buying a fund right before a massive distribution. NOVIX has had a couple of the disproportionately large distribution in its history but nowhere close to the one for $9.

Last month we looked at a Bloomberg article about "dividend nomads," some of whom live off of distributions from derivative income funds. The Trillions podcast did a follow up on the article that was fun to listen to. Hosts Eric and Joel had the writer of the article on (make sense) and an advisor who doesn't have any clients doing this so I don't know why he was on. The general take was that it can work with funds that have JEPI-like yield but it would be optimal. 

That's pretty similar to our conclusion but there does need to be an ability/willingness to live on less of a pay out in a down market. The S&P 500 isn't going to go out of business so any fund referencing the S&P 500 and not incinerating its NAV should also not go out of business. That doesn't mean it's optimal, just that there's not much risk of it completely failing. Here's one that I think is an NAV incinerator, continuing to erode quickly and eventually reverse splitting.


I don't think JEPI or SPYI are NAV incinerators. Living on derivative fund income still probably better thought of as a bridge to the next financial milestone rather than something a 40 year old FIRE guy should plan on sustaining for 50 years. 


Those are price only returns and you can see the income levels for $500,000 invested. These portfolios are not very robust. 100% in JEPI has no robustness. Putting 10% into BTAL potentially becomes a source of funds if the market drops a lot causing distributions to go down. If the S&P 500 drops 30%, the need to hedge with BTAL or anything else becomes less. You probably don't need to hedge against a large decline after a large decline. Mixing SPYI and CAIE isn't really diversifying, they both reference the S&P 500. Portfolio 3 has a higher yield than the ones that own JEPI but I don't think of that as NAV incinerating but I would expect erosion if the market has smaller gains than it has in recent years. Portfolio 3 wouldn't owe taxes for a while as both funds return capital for their distributions. You can look up why that is if you are unfamiliar. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Linear Modeling, Lumpy Living

In response to yesterday's post about living on dividends without spending principal, a buddy left a comment on Bluesky noting the strategy/idea is more difficult than it seems which is where the title for this post comes from. At his suggestion I took a look at a preferred stock ETF and I threw in PFD which is a closed end fund that invests in preferred stocks. 


IUSB has been no great shakes either but yikes for PFD and PFF which is an iShares Preferred Stock ETF. Preferreds sound good in theory but they are tough to live with in practice. This was also the case for individual bank preferred stocks in the Financial Crisis, they got pasted. 

I try to really hit on what it's like to actually own various types of assets and strategies versus just looking at a pretty backtest. 


Managed futures always backtests fantastically well as part of a diversified portfolio, gold too to a lesser extent but nine years is a very long time to compound at zero. A 3-5% diversifier is one thing but 25% is something else entirely. It's not that a portfolio couldn't succeed in that nine year period but sitting with a huge allocation to something that isn't growing for nine years will be very challenging. 


The portfolio with 25% in GLD had a two year run in the middle where it lagged noticeably but the overall nine year period, the back test is fine. I know 25% in one alt is the wrong path for me, I'm not saying it's wrong for anyone else, you all can decide for yourself, but it is important to consider what enduring a long stretch of an asset just sitting there doing nothing would feel like if it happened again. 


If I was forced to own just one fund, I guess it would be BLNDX. It's hard to argue with that backtest. It has delivered in terms of the expectation that I believe the managers set when the fund launched. I doubt that the period inside the purple box would have bee very challenging as it went sideways while 60/40 had very painful drawdown. During the period in the green box though, BLNDX again traded sideways while 60/40 did very well. If BLNDX does well because it is willing to differentiating, that's part of the story, then anyone buying the fund needs to be ready for a repeat of the pattern in the green box or maybe worse.

Actually the idea for BLNDX came about because as strong of a diversifier that managed futures is, it is very difficult for many investors to hold on through thick and through thin. Blending the two is an attempt to solve that problem. 

It's easy to throw a bunch of things into testfol.io and play around until you get something that looks good but hopefully you also take my context of trying to paint of a picture of what owning these various alts and strategies will actually be like, repeated for emphasis. 

One last point.


The blue line portfolio is a variation of an idea we looked at a couple of weeks ago that puts 60% into diverse alts and 20% each to equities and fixed income. The backtest is fantastic but look at the year by year results.


How difficult would it have been to stick with it after stumbling out of the starting blocks and that three year period where the lag was enormous?

Linear modeling, lumpy living. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Living On A Dividend

From Ben Carlson;


Is it realistic? How realistic is it? What parts are realistic? In his blog post Ben talked about the mechanics of how dividends work. If you have $100 in stock and the company pays out $1 in dividends, you now have $99 worth of stock and $1 in cash. If you spend the dollar, then you just have $99 in stock and that's it. Maybe I misunderstood but he seemed to discount the idea because of these mechanics and needing to price appreciate that $1 in dividends back.

He did say that just living off the dividends without touching the principal was the "retirement dream." People like dividends/distributions so the better questions is can a dividend-centric portfolio in this context outgrow its yield? If so, then it is at least partly realistic.


Quite clearly is it possible. The above three funds' numbers go back to late 2011, those are price only returns. Whether owning one or more dividend ETFs is a good idea or optimal is another discussion but if the stock market goes up most of the time, it is a reasonable probability that dividend funds that are not crazy high yielders or NAV incinerators can have a growth rate that exceeds its yield. The next time we have a lost decade that might not be the case but then if we have a lost decade, growth for simple market cap weighting would also be lost. 


This mix allows us to backtest just over 20 years. I've owned JNJ and BNS for clients since 2004. I owned MO back then but switched to PM when the company split. 


Using BTAL speaks to the reader's concern about drawdowns. Having 10% in BTAL brings down the volatility and helps with drawdowns but there are some declines that portfolios can't hide from. 

But, 2008 was the only calendar year where the price only version exceeded a 15% decline. There were a handful of very fast declines though where the 15% level was breached. That could be offset with more than 10% in BTAL but the more in BTAL, the less that is producing income. There's a tradeoff here that the reader would need to sort out. 

Here's an updated version that swaps out 20% in IEF for 20% in SHRIX. This allows us to go back 10 years. 

We're getting far more income obviously which is what the reader wants but the tradeoff is a lower price only growth rate.


There's still 6.8% in growth after taking out the income versus an inflation rate of 3.39% for the period tested. The dividends for the stocks and ETF should be qualified but not the dividends from SHRIX. 

This can work with tradeoffs. Here's an example of something that probably can't work as a long term plan.


Funds like JEPI, SPYI or BALI have distributions in this neighborhood. 

That goes back to mid-2013 and actually is better than I expected as I was typing the previous sentence. Adjusted for inflation, SPXX compounded at a negative 0.48% and XYLD negative 2.33%. While this is not a great long term portfolio strategy, we've looked at this sort of thing in the context of a bucket strategy needing to last maybe eight-ten years to get someone to the next financial milestone like Social Security or RMDs. Success here is not riding out SPXX for 30 years but being willing to exhaust a smaller piece of money over a much shorter period. 

Success would be something like hoping make this type of bucket or bridge last for 10 years like I said, getting to ten years having depleted most of it but maybe having enough leftover for an emergency fund. In 2016 someone did this with $400,000, they've been taking a long term unsustainable $40,000 out per year and instead of having zero today in that account (which would be ok), they have $100,000 left over for a robust emergency fund. Saying it more plainly, you expect to deplete the account but instead you have some left over. That is plausible, counting on 11% forever is probably doomed because of longer term growth rates not being that high and loss of purchasing power.

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Monday, November 09, 2026

Looking At Leverage

The Monday email from Finominal looked at whether there is any added benefit to leveraging up investment portfolios. My use of the word up is not fair, really the idea is whether using leverage for better diversification is additive. The following is what they studied.


We can't go back 100 years on testfol.io but I think we can go far enough back to be useful.


The result for 90/60 being better than straight S&P 500 is consistent with the backtesting done by WisdomTree to support their NTSX ETF. The next image adjusts the growth rates for inflation. 


A real return of 5% is a common target for endowments. Portfolio 4 obviously has the lowest growth rate but it also has the lowest volatility by far and a pretty small max drawdown when you think about all the crazy things that have happened since 1988 and the beta is only 0.18. All good but the differences in compounding is meaningful. Portfolio 4 has grown to $224,000 while simple 60/40 is $335,000. Yes 100% equities did much better than both but someone really needs to look themselves in the mirror about going 100% equities and being able to hold on no matter what. 

Someone could put it all in NTSX, so levered up, but that would have meant being down almost 30% in 2022 versus 18-19% for SPY/IEF. The math checks out of course but enduring 30% requires enduing 30%. There's not a tidy this is best for everyone answer here. We talk frequently about understanding our own emotional limits for our investment portfolio as well as the tradeoffs to whatever we decide. Going full NTSX should result in a better long term result but with more pain along the way. Portfolio 4 is very unlikely to keep up with the others but I would expect very little anguish along the way. 

Where this exercise is quadrant inspired, the Permanent Portfolio Fund PRPFX compounded at 7.08% for the period studied with a volatility of 8.94%. I feel like most of the investment industry would consider the permanent portfolio idea to be valid but clearly not always optimal but then nothing is always optimal. 

I don't think it is that difficult to assess the pros and cons of most of the portfolios we explore here. With today's example, a portfolio with a 25% weight to equities might be all weatherish, I would say Portfolio 4 fits that bill, it's not going to keep up with a portfolio that is 60% equities. 

The other day, we used a Twitter fight as an opportunity to look at a new (to us) ETF that fits in with some of other funds that we've looked at over the last few weeks. Over the weekend, the Twitter fight drew a lot more attention, really a lot. I think this screenshot gives some context of how the instigator engages on Twitter.


The Hedgeye company that McCullough runs is a research shop, they have some ETFs and there is a very active trading service. Hedgeye's runs a lot of ads about learning their process which includes a universe of 140 ETFs that allows them to "go anywhere, not everywhere." 


Based on all the back and forth I read over the weekend (I couldn't help it!), the success is very questionable but there are plenty of people (or bots maybe, I don't know) that were very supportive of Hedgeye. But the 140 ETFs and I also believe there are individual stocks involved too, is interesting to me. 

The trading appears to be very active and if they exercise all 140 ETFs frequently, that is going to be hard to keep track of. This all helped me crystalize a couple of things we do here that I hope are productive for readers but that I know helps me.

You have probably noticed that when we explore portfolio theory we use a much narrower universe of funds. I am very much a believer in holding long term when possible. By using far fewer funds for blogging purposes I think it creates the effect for regular readers to get a sense how these funds do through various events. I first started writing about SHRIX for cat bonds three years ago. Cat bonds are a core holding, the weighting is small though, and most portfolios we experiment with include SHRIX. Love the idea or hate it, if you're reading this blog regularly you are getting a sense of how they do. 

There are others too of course, cat bonds is just an easy example. Clients own EMPIX, not SHRIX, SHRIX has a much longer track record which makes for better backtesting. EMPIX is managed to have even less volatility than SHRIX which is why I prefer that one. 

The continuity makes it much easier to learn versus being all over the place with very frequent trading changes. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

A Model Of Complexity

On Friday, Finominal wrote about Global X Moderate Aggressive ETF Portfolio. Here are a couple of screen shots to list them all out. Kudos t...