Saturday, November 21, 2026

A Model Of Complexity

On Friday, Finominal wrote about Global X Moderate Aggressive ETF Portfolio. Here are a couple of screen shots to list them all out.



Kudos to them first of all for using funds from other fund providers in their models, not all providers do that. They even have very narrow based funds from other providers too like SKYY and PBE. If you count though, that's 26 ETFs, that is a lot for a model portfolio, really a lot. 

Finominal notes that the portfolio has a 25% weighting to fixed income but that the fixed income sleeve doesn't contribute any risk because it is mostly short duration. It looks like there are seven fixed income funds assuming PFFD is in the equity sleeve. Seven could probably be winnowed down to two funds, maybe even one. BUG, HERO and QTUM are all narrow, themed funds that each have less than a 1% weighting. 

The portfolio critique picked on owning both DYNF and QUS. I noticed that too but they do differ from each other.

And weighted proportionally, the DYNF/QUS combo did better than SPY for the last five years.


They suggest simplifying the portfolio with 80% ACWI/20% AGG. The portfolio as presented seems more complex than necessary for the value added (it lags the 80/20 benchmark but has a higher Sharpe Ratio) but two funds is probably too simple.

Amplify threw its hat into the autocallable ring with YO that in addition to a high targeted yield of SOFR plus 8%, it also offers a 25% downside buffer. The expectation should not be no sensitivity to equity market volatility, it was down 2.23% on Friday, but if the buffer works, it will protect based on the maturity of the notes held in the fund which is five years. This past week is an indication that five years is a long time to wait for the buffer to protect your investment. There is also a mechanism where any missed coupon payments due to a very large decline could be made up when the underlying recovers. Note the key word is could, could be made up. 

Most of these really are hot sauce, if you want to dabble, I would go small. I'm going to continue to study these but the only ones I would consider for clients would be the two from Janus. High, single digit yields is still a fantastic yield with nowhere near the volatility of the rest of the space. ACSP from ProShares targets 18-19% and as Dennis Eckersley might say, it moves 5% in either direction just to stay in shape.  

Here's a chart with a few funds we've looked at recently and also a few from a while ago versus VBAIX. The context is whether they could be replacements for VBAIX.


PRPFX is the outlier to the downside in the current event due to its large weighting to gold. Here's how they did for 2022 except for ENDW which wasn't around yet.

The chart is price only so that huge drop off for AQRIX was its annual distribution. I think the point of these last two charts is to reiterate that valid strategies cannot always be the best strategies. 

As a quick follow up on DYMIX that we mentioned yesterday. It will be paying out a 19% distribution which the fund literature says will be taxed as ordinary income. That doesn't matter in an IRA, just reinvest and be done with it. For taxable accounts though, that's a big hit. DYMIX is useful for studying what macro funds can do but I don't see ever using it. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

No comments:

A Model Of Complexity

On Friday, Finominal wrote about Global X Moderate Aggressive ETF Portfolio. Here are a couple of screen shots to list them all out. Kudos t...