Tuesday, September 12, 2023

Covered Call Funds To Add Volatility?

Steve Laipply from iShares was on ETFIQ on Bloomberg Monday talking primarily about fixed income ETFs. Included in iShares fixed income lineup are three bond ETF buywrite funds. So the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond Buywrite ETF (TLTW) essentially owns TLT, a long duration bond fund, and sells covered calls against the shares of TLT. iShares also has Investment Grade Corporate Bond Buywrite ETF (LQDW) which corresponds to LQD and there is also the iShares High Yield Bond Buywrite ETF (HYGW) which corresponds to HYG.

The yields on these are sky high. If you look at Yahoo finance you'll see high teens looking back, Laipply said they've come down some to the low to mid teens which is still very high of course. Something to keep in mind as we go through this is we are currently in a 5% world. If you can find 6% or 7% somewhere then you are taking a little more risk but a 15% yield in a 5% world takes on a lot of risk. That's a point that cannot be minimized. Here are charts comparing the original to the buywrite versions YTD.

 

 


The funds started in mid-2022 but giving the benefit of the doubt, I will assume that last year was an anomaly in terms of magnitude of decline.

 

I'll just throw in one since inception chart for context but all three look similarly bad in the same time frame.

The LQDW/LQD chart shows what can go wrong. They went down in lockstep which is ok. Then LQD started to rally and it looks like LQDW stopped at the strike price of an option sold (pegged was the jargon 25 years ago) and missed a huge bounce from November into December. From there, the charts look similar. Sticking with LQDW/LQD, Yahoo Finance says LQDW is up 5.13% YTD on a total return basis versus 2.01% for the underlying LQD. TLTW total return this year is 3.94% and TLT is -3.17%. HYGW total return this year is 6.82% while HYG is 5.41%.

These can work but one problem is they may not be able to bounce back after a crash. There are probably other problems that could arise as well, remember these pay 15% (very rounded) in a 5% world.

With the bond buywrite ETFs, the prices of the funds are not keeping up with the ex-dividend reductions which puts the possibility of depletion on the table.

Single stock, covered call ETFs is another new type of product add to this conversation. Let's look at a couple of those. You can go to the YieldMax site to look at more of them. I chose Apple (AAPL/APLY) and Nvidia (NVDA/NVDY) because they're part of the first batch so we have a longer track record to look at. To be clear, these have not been around very long. 

 

 

Portfoliovisualizer is showing total return, not just price performance. In terms of just price performance the numbers are quite different. With Apple, the covered call ETF lags the common almost 13% and with NVDA, the covered call ETF lags the common by 45%. The YieldMax website says the distribution (annual) yields for the NVDA and AAPL products are 49% and 14% respectively. I don't really understand why it is ok to project a yield based on the vagaries of the options market but apparently they can. The stocks that have been packaged into the YieldMax products are a mix of hot potatoes like NVDA and TSLA where the "yield" is in the forties and more mature tech names with yields in the mid teens. 

It's a 5% world so there's plenty of risk with a 15% yielder, all the more so with a 40% yielder. 

Between starting this post on Monday night and finishing on Tuesday, I stumbled into the Kraneshares China Internet and Covered Call Strategy ETF (KLIP) which is the Kraneshares China Internet ETF (KWEB) with a covered call overlay. KLIP started in January, is a monthly pay and so far has paid out about $8 against it's current price just under $18.00. The fund came out at $25 so it is down $7 and has paid out $8.


Note that Portfoliovisualizer doesn't pick up January but if I grabbed the chart from Yahoo, it wouldn't pick up the dividends. The idea of eight steps forward and seven steps back seems like a tough way to make a living but it's worth studying.

Covered call strategies are often packaged as a way to reduce volatility. The funds we've looked at in this post might technically do that, not certain, but either way they are not themselves low vol products. These are proliferating. As I looked for information to write this, I got served ads on Google for all sorts of covered call funds I've never heard of before. 


If you're going dabble in any of these, dabble is probably a good way to size these if at all, make sure you understand what you're getting. TLTW in its short life has had a higher standard deviation than the S&P 500 with just a fraction of the return. These funds can play a role in a diversified portfolio. There are probably multiple ways to slot in a small exposure including barbelling yield. I don't mean building a fixed income barbell, I mean barbelling volatility/yield such where a small allocation to a couple of these hot potatoes provides a disproportionately high percentage of a portfolio's income. 10% split between one of the bond ETF buywrite funds and single stock covered call ETF with the other 90% in a 5% T-bill doesn't seem like an unreasonable concept to consider while these things give a better sense of what they will actually do. 

I have always been intrigued by covered calls and funds that use the strategy. For all of my interest here, I still have only dabbled in these which is worth pointing out. 

The information, analysis and opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and opinions as of the date of writing and are subject to change at any time without notice. They are not intended to constitute legal, tax, securities or investment advice or a recommended course of action in any given situation.

Sunday, September 10, 2023

Barron's Breaks Down Working In Retirement

Barron's had a couple of good articles this weekend looking at working past normal retirement age. The articles overlapped some and both covered ground that we've been talking about here for 19 years. This month will be the 19th anniversary of the original Random Roger blog. Here is one link and then here is the other. 

The first article, the blue link, looks at people working into their 80's. The range of circumstances goes from an 85 year old woman who works as a greeter at Lowes who doesn't have much money and has to support one of her grandchildren to an instructor at a community college teaching technical courses related to semiconductor manufacturing. 

A starting point for me is the economic need. We get told repeatedly how low 401k and IRA balances are. Harsh reality is that many people simply will not end up accumulating enough to retire in the sense of stopping work altogether. Various types of part time gigs can be the answer, it doesn't have to mean staying in a job you hate until you're 80 or dead. 

We've looked at examples before where a couple who at 60 are undersaved could have a chance of catching up by working until 70 and saving much more than they have been presuming they are now mortgage free. Harsh reality is that if you're 60, have $250,000 and no visibility for meaningfully increasing your savings rate, you're going to come up short. That amount of money can certainly create an income stream but that circumstance likely would need additional income streams beyond Social Security. That could be jobs, monetizing a hobby, some sort of "passive" income or maybe something else. 

I put passive in quotes there because passive still requires work to be done either by the retiree or paying someone else. Example; we have a cabin we rent out short term on Airbnb. It has to be cleaned every time of course. Either we can do it which means more money for us or we could hire someone to come clean it which would be less money for us. We clean it now but if we stick with this until we are old, we're going to need to outsource but either way, work is involved.  

The second article, linked above in red, went over the benefits of working one way or another to an "old"age which are financial of course but also there's plenty there related to successful aging. The engagement, mental stimulation and the physical activity keep people healthier for longer and stave off depression and dementia. 

Invariably, there will be a comment or two questioning the motive of the author to suggest working later or waiting to take Social Security in those types of articles. I don't think it is necessary for people who have what they need financially to still work but some sort of thing that gives structure, purpose and as mentioned above engagement, mental stimulation and physical activity is still crucial to aging successfully. 

What things do you love doing? Whatever the answer, do those things. If they pay, fine, if not, fine. If you're reading this blog, you're less likely to need the money when the time comes but IMO, we all need the engagement and all the rest that goes with staying very active. 


The housing on top of Walker Fire Engine 86 where we fill water rusted out. Three of our guys (two firefighters and our station boss) fixed it yesterday. A couple of weeks ago, one of them fabricated a new housing and then they installed it. The two firefighters are 67 and our station boss is probably 82. There were many trips up and down from the top of the truck both on the foot pegs and a ladder. All three guys are very engaged with the department. They all epitomize successful aging. 

There's no money here obviously but what's the difference? The guys who are 67 (68 now?) both packtested this past spring. The packtest is a 3 mile hike in 45 minutes or less wearing a 45 pound pack that is the annual physical standard to fight a wildfire. Aside from the desire to engage with the fire department, all three have favorable body composition for aging which is to say none of them have big guts. Yes, more diet and exercise stuff from me but the odds for successful aging go way up when you avoid gaining weight as you get older. Lift weights and cut carbs.

It is never too late to solve problems or make improvements. A 60 year old who is undersaved and overweight can help themselves on both fronts. And if someone simply cannot make meaningful financial improvements in the manner outlined above, physical improvements will give more optionality for eventually addressing the financial issue later. If you get fit, you'll have more options for what you can do to keep working. 

I've been preaching this here since I was 38, I'm 57 now. Some of the details have evolved as I have learned more but I've walked the walked and can tell you life is much easier when you make just a few good financial decisions early on and stay at least moderately fit. From there, life becomes far more fulfilling with active engagements beyond your day job.

A Model Of Complexity

On Friday, Finominal wrote about Global X Moderate Aggressive ETF Portfolio. Here are a couple of screen shots to list them all out. Kudos t...